Common Problems
- I completed all criteria and didn't get Insane in the Membrane Achievement or Title
- I was Honored with Bloodsail Buccaneers before grinding Goblin rep, but didn't get Insane in the Membrane achievement after getting Exalted with all of the Goblin factions
- If I lose reputation with the Bloodsail Buccaneers while I'm working on Booty Bay, will I still be able to get the achievement?
Modern WoW
In Modern WoW, the Insane in the Membrane achievement is still available and can be completed. It is a single character achievement, so reputation gains on additional characters will not count towards the achievement.
While you do not have to have all the reputations simultaneously, there are community recommendations for the easiest way to complete this achievement for tracking reputations. Check Wowhead's Insane in the Membrane guide for more information.
Mists of Pandaria Classic
Right now this Achievement is not obtainable due to a known Bug with the Shendralar reputation incorrectly being required. We are working on fixing this as quickly as possible.
Once fixed, so long as you have the correct reps currently active, the Achievement should trigger. We don't expect this to be retroactive, so strongly recommend not swapping reputations around, doing so will mean the Achievement won't trigger and the criteria must be completed again.